Sermon
Rev.
Rosemary Pantling
7th September 2008
16th Sunday after Trinity
Our
Church is dedicated to the Nativity of the Virgin Mary
The
Virgin Mary – the Perfect Role Model?
Luke 1 26-38
What
would you put on a list of the qualities you look for in
the perfect friend?
-be
successful at their jobs
-have
2.4 perfectly behaved children who never quarrel and
keep their rooms tidy without being asked.
-invite
you to four-course cordon bleu meals in their immaculate
houses.
-arrive
everywhere absolutely on time,
-remember your birthday
-know
the immediate answer to any problem you might have,
whether the best route from here to Birmingham airport
or how to get stains out of the carpet?
I very
much doubt that any of these things are on your list.
In fact my perfect friend has an equally untidy
house to mine, two equally exasperating children, with
whom she loses her temper at least as often as I do, and
definitely has to have as many faults and make as many
mistakes as I do, because that’s how I know she
understands me, and I can tell her about my failures
without feeling she’ll look down on me.
Now all
this is by way of introduction to what I want to say
next:
I have
a
problem with the Virgin Mary.
And my
problem is that she is so often held up as an example of
perfection.
I do know that for centuries many Christians, especially
Christian women, have found her an inspiration and a
comfort. But
for many modern women, and I know I’m not alone in this,
the meek, submissive, innocent perfect woman is so far
from what I am, or even what I aspire to, that I
struggle with what to make of her.
However, as so often is the case, it helps to go back to
the Bible, and try to let go of centuries of Christian
art, myth and legend, which have added to our perception
of Mary all sorts of things which just aren’t there in
the little we know of her.
And
then I find a Mary with whom I can identify more easily.
Firstly, she definitely didn’t know it all.
Her immediate reaction to he angel’s message:
“Mary was greatly troubled at his words and wondered
what kind of greeting this might be”. (v 29)
This reminds us
of what Luke also says after the shepherds have visited,
“Mary treasured all these words and pondered
them in her heart.” (Lk 2.19)
Here is
a Mary we can identify with.
One who was puzzled, had to think about things,
had to try and work out what was going on. Remember how
young she was, if she is not yet married she is probably
a very young teenager.
Mary was not someone with everything nicely
worked out and sorted, not someone with all the answers.
In fact I very much doubt she ever did understand
it all.
What a
comfort this Mary is.
God doesn’t ask us to be sure and certain of
everything, he doesn’t mind that we carry questions with
us, perhaps for the whole of our lives, we don’t need a
perfect understanding of every teaching about God to
believe in him and serve him.
And so
despite her uncertainty, Mary says, “I am the Lord’s
servant, May it be to me as you have said.”
So the
Mary of the Bible, the one we can identify with is
obedient.
I don’t
think she did it without a fight though.
She did question the angel after all.
“ How will this be, since I am a virgin?”
“Hold on a minute, I can’t have a baby
because I haven’t slept with a man.”
We all
are called to do God’s will and serve him in the way we
believe he wants us to, but being obedient to him
requires us to be quite certain of what he wants in the
first place.
He’s given us common sense and it is not wrong to
struggle to be sure we are doing the right thing.
This is
a Mary with whom I can identify, a friend who can
understand me.
Mary doesn’t understand it all, but she tries to
serve God.
But now
we come to the problem, perhaps the biggest problem for
modern Christians -the issue of Mary’s virginity.
I don’t want to get sidetracked here, but what I
would like to ask is, why has it become such a big deal?
Why, the moment a Bishop admits something like:
“some Christians have a problem with the virgin
birth,” do we get silly headlines saying “Bishop denies
virgin birth”?
Because it is important to be able to discuss it,
and to especially to look at what some Christians have
added to this belief.
You
will know that some believe that Mary remained a virgin
for the rest of her life.
We today are celebrating the Nativity of the
Virgin Mary, Mary’s own birth.
There are many Christians who believe that in
order for Mary to be pure enough to bear Jesus, when her
parents conceived her it was a special conception, an
immaculate conception, so that she herself was conceived
without sin.
Neither
the belief in the Immaculate Conception of Mary, nor the
belief that she remained a Virgin for life, are required
to be held by Anglicans. We should however be willing to
think about what Christians seem to say about the
physical marriage relationship when they do hold such
beliefs.
Mary is
a strange a role model for the perfect wife if she
remains a virgin when the Church teaches that the
physical relationship between man and wife is a vital
and God-given part of the marriage bond.
As I said, the only part of this which actually
comes from the Bible, and which is therefore part of
Anglican belief, is that Mary was a virgin when she
conceived Jesus.
But
Christians should be allowed to admit that they find it
difficult to believe that Jesus was conceived to a
virgin mother.
We should allow them to discuss that, and ponder
that, and think carefully about what it is about the
virgin birth that matters to those of us who do hold
that belief.
Because
what is sad is that while we get het up over the odd
misleading quotation in the press we might be missing
the real message.
The gospel passage we heard read today is just
not interested in the physical body which gave birth to
Christ. What
it is telling us is the amazing exciting
extraordinary fact that God has become a human being.
Emmanuel he is called, which as you know means
God with us.
The
incarnation.
Everything that God essentially is, becoming everything
that essentially we are.
A real
normal human birth from a real normal human body, giving
us a real human baby who grew to be a real human child
and a real human adult.
That’s
what we can relate to.
Mary being a normal human mother, with the same
love and concern for her child as any human parent.
Mary, and Joseph, having to do the normal
physical caring for their child, and the normal
nurturing and teaching and worrying and scolding no
doubt.
Because
only then is Jesus a real human being, who can be my
perfect friend.
A friend who has lived in a family where there
will have been quarrels and not everything will have
been perfect all the time.
A
friend who knows that we make mistakes, that we hurt and
get hurt, that life is complex and muddled and
difficult.
We give thanks
for Mary today, as our patron saint, because without her
the incarnation would not have happened.
The real human that she was, not the perfect
myth, who did not know it all, was willing to ponder and
puzzle, who was willing to serve God but in the course
of that to argue it out with God and then say yes, OK
I’ll do it, she it was who brought Jesus into the world.
And that flawed Mary is our perfect role model,
out perfect patron saint.
An ordinary real person just like us.
So just
as she brought Christ into the world by a real human
birth, so we too can bring the incarnate Christ into the
lives of those around us.
Through
us, imperfect, puzzled, not wholly convinced, but
ultimately willing to try, through us Jesus comes.
We are the ones who can speak his words, offer
his love and show him in all sorts of ways to a world
who has forgotten him.
So our
prayer as we give thanks for Mary and try to follow
Mary’s example, is to offer to do our imperfect best to
serve God.
Then
with Mary we can say: “Here am I, the servant of the
Lord, let it be with me according to your word.”
|